(347) 546-6746 mendelr@pandginsurance.com
MBR RISK ADVISORS Start a 15-Minute Call
Senior Care Compliance Guide

Your liability premium isn't rising because insurers stopped liking you.

Professional and general liability claims in senior care have gotten bigger, not just more frequent — and underwriters have changed what they price to. Here's what's actually driving the 2026 market, and what to have ready before your renewal.

Start a 15-Minute Discovery Call See Senior Living Coverage
Avg. PL indemnity, 2024$253,000
Same figure in 2019$179,000
Memory care claim severity~23% higher
Falls' share of case volume40–54%
What's Actually Driving the Numbers

It's not more claims. It's bigger ones.

Frequency in senior care liability has stayed relatively steady in most states. Severity hasn't. A handful of claim types are pulling the average up, and they're not evenly distributed across your business.

Falls Are Still the Core Exposure

Falls account for 40–54% of case volume depending on facility type, and result in death in 40–45% of fall cases. Dementia is present in 76% of assisted living fall claims — and pressure ulcers show up in 72% of cases, two-thirds of which involve a resident death.

Memory Care Costs More to Defend

Memory care claims average roughly 23% higher than non-memory-care claims. If memory care is part of your census, it's part of what your underwriter is pricing separately — whether your renewal quote spells that out or not.

Geography Isn't Neutral

California represents about 9% of senior care case volume nationally but roughly 15% of total dollars paid out. Venue matters to severity as much as your own loss history does.

What Underwriters Are Actually Pricing To

Clean loss history is the floor now, not the differentiator.

1

Staffing & Documentation

Staffing levels, turnover, and how consistently care is documented — not just whether an incident happened, but whether the record shows it was handled correctly.

2

Five-Year Loss Trend

Underwriters look at the trend line, not a single good or bad year. A rough year with a clear corrective response reads differently than the same year with no follow-up.

3

Maintenance & Compliance Records

Facility maintenance logs and regulatory compliance history are now standard underwriting inputs, used to separate otherwise similar-looking risks.

Why "We Haven't Had a Claim" Isn't Enough Anymore

A clean history gets you a quote. Documented process gets you a competitive one.

For years, a facility with a quiet loss history could expect a reasonably priced renewal almost automatically. That's no longer how most markets underwrite senior care. A clean record shows you haven't been unlucky yet — it doesn't show underwriters how you'd actually respond to a fall, a pressure ulcer, or a wandering incident if one happened tomorrow.

What's changed is that carriers can now ask for that proof directly: fall-prevention protocols, staffing ratios by shift, incident documentation practices, and how quickly issues get escalated and corrected. Facilities that can produce that paperwork are seeing more markets willing to compete for their business. Facilities that can't are seeing fewer admitted carriers quote at all, regardless of how quiet their claims history has actually been.

Property remains comparatively soft right now, with named-storm deductibles easing for well-documented portfolios. General and professional liability is the line where the real underwriting scrutiny — and the real premium movement — is happening in 2026.

Before Your Next Renewal

What to have ready when we shop your program.

Fall-prevention protocol

Your written protocol and evidence it's actually followed — not just that one exists on paper.

Staffing & turnover data

Ratios by shift and recent turnover trends. Underwriters read staffing gaps as a leading indicator of claims, not a lagging one.

Memory care-specific documentation

If you operate a memory care unit, protocols specific to wandering, elopement, and dementia-related fall risk, kept separate from general care documentation.

Five-year loss run

A clean, current loss run with narrative context for any large or unusual claims — what happened, and what changed afterward.

Claims severity and case-mix figures cited above are drawn from The Baldwin Group's 2026 Senior Living Industry Report, a mid-year market analysis compiled from industry claims and underwriting data. Figures reflect industry-wide averages and are not a projection for any specific facility. Source: baldwin.com.

Renewal coming up? Let's see where you actually stand.

Send us your current program and loss history and we'll tell you straight what the market will and won't move on — no obligation, no jargon.

Request My Discovery Call
Prefer email? mendelr@pandginsurance.com or call (347) 546-6746